In 1985, Shawn and Henry are sitting outside on a picnic table. Henry is reading the paper, while Shawn is busy looking for the prize in the bottom of the cereal box. His dad explains that is a waste of time worrying about what's not the box. His dad tells him that they messed up, so he grabs another box and asks Shawn were it is. He tells him that it is at the bottom of the box. He then complains that he has to eat the whole box to get to it. His dad flips it over and now that it is at the top Shawn opens the box to get his mood ring.
Present day, Shawn and Gus crash a crime scene of an apparent suicide. One of several in the last few months. This one was an overdose of pills, or so it seems. While in the apartment, though, Shawn notices a few things that might point more toward murder. When no one believes his psychic vision of foul play, he insists he's not leaving until he talks to the witness - the victim's cat.
Even Gus has a hard time believing murder until another body is found. Shawn, Gus and the cat arrive at the second crime scene to find a woman who apparently killed herself by shutting herself in her garage with the car running. Even though a suicide note is written in black eyeliner on the windshield, Shawn still doesn't believe it, and he and the cat point out more inconsistencies with the suicide theory. Lassiter and Juliet O'Hara are starting to believe.
Shawn and Gus are even more convinced after they discover the latest victim just got her big acting break in a local play. No way she would kill herself after that.
Meanwhile, Officer McNab's wedding is getting closer and he's starting to get nervous about the wedding night. He goes to Lassiter for advice, which needless to say, does not go well. Just then, Shawn, Gus and the cat arrive to tell Interim Chief Vick that the cat doesn't think these are suicides. She tells them she can't reopen the cases based on a cat's intuition.
Since Shawn and Gus can't find any pattern in the killings, they decide to go back to the beginning - the crime scene of the very first victim, David Hildenbach.
They go to his apartment, where his brother Wes still lives. From Wes they learn that David was a talented musician who was going places. There were no signs of depression. While there, Shawn also 'liberates' an old phone bill from the apartment. It turns out that there are several calls to a stress line, including one made the day he died. Gus says that's not really proof of anything. If he were depressed, it would make sense he'd called a stress line. Shawn thinks this could be the link between the victims they've been looking for.
They find out from Juliet that all the victims called the stress line many times in the days before they died. Juliet says that just proves they were all troubled people, who in the end took their lives but Shawn thinks it's even more proof that something weird is going on. Someone at the stress line must be killing the callers and making it look like suicide.
At the stress line, they meet a volunteer named Rory Derkins, who wears eyeliner and is working there as community service on an assault charge. At the same time, Lassiter and Juliet are running backgrounds on all the volunteers there. One in particular catches Lassiter's eye. Turns out, he was the one who arrested Rory in the first place.
The police arrive and arrest Rory for the murders. But as he's defending himself, Shawn notices a guy from the phone company outside. This triggers memories of several encounters with a phone technician in the past week. So as Gus is thinking Lassiter has bogarted their big reveal, Shawn is now rethinking their suspect.
When they head outside to catch the phone guy, they find he's gone, but in his haste, he's left his receiver behind. With it, he could listen to the incoming calls into the line. Plus, all the dates of the murders coincide with when he was working on the phones. It all fits. They check the last number on the receiver to find his next victim - it's McNab.
They call the police and race over to McNab's to stop the killer, who turns out to be Wes Hildenbach. Wes didn't kill his brother, but he did watch him throw himself off the roof. He was angry that he was weak, and became angry at everyone else who was weak, everyone who called the stress line in need of help. The tense stand off between Wes and the cops ends with some timely heroics by the cat, which Shawn generously gifts to McNab as a wedding present.
- The ailurophile contention that felines are gifted with multiple 'get out of jail free' cards in the course of their existence provides the title.
- When Shawn was channeling the dead woman he started his dance the same way he did when preforming for Mr. Yang in "Psych: The Musical."
- A pineapple appears when Shawn and Gus visit the stress line and bring a pineapple as a gift.
- "Little boy cat" is calico.. not a boy....
The gallery for 9 Lives can be found here.